Truth? I kind of love an occasional trip to Five Guys. For all my preaching about industrialized beef and fast food and GOOD GOD ALL THE GREASE, about three times a year I need a giant styrofoam cup of fries. I feel like death afterwards, but for about 20 minutes, it's worth it.
And last night was one of those nights when a burger was a good idea, when the husband and I decided to see what all the fuss was about on Emmet Street. C'ville has plenty of Five Guys locations. But Cook-Out, the North Carolina chain, recently opened. The parking lot and drive-thru were so busy, they had a guy directing traffic. We were barely inside the door and the line kept growing. Thankfully, we were handed a menu and were able to make our choices before reaching the counter (though, if they had an automated way to place orders, we're sure things would go A LOT faster -- take note, owners). I pounced on a table vacated by some UVa undergrads (who populated the place) and patiently waited for my food.
Our order? A Cheddar Style burger (with cheddar, grilled onions, mayo, and bacon), a Cook-Out Style burger (chili, slaw, mustard, and onions), fries, a large Cheerwine, and a chocolate shake (my apologies for a lack of photos).
The verdict? Five Guys wins.
The fries were good and better than most fast food fries, but in no way compare to what Five Guys shovels into that brown paper bag. Ketchup was Heinz (WIN), but in packets which are difficult to open with greasy fingers. My burger was a little heavy on the onions and so hot I almost burned my mouth. I felt a little forced to order one of the speciality burgers, when I would've rather picked my own toppings. I don't know if this was because of the crowd or the reputation. The husband (who is about as anti-fast food as I am) even thought a Five Guys burger was better and he almost never goes there. With that said, the chocolate shake was smooth, thick, and just chocolaty enough, and I'd sit in a drive-thru line for another one.
I think we wanted to like it more than we did. Maybe once the mad rush dies down, we'll give it another shot. Yes, it's cheaper than Five Guys, but you get what you pay for, and honestly? I'd rather pay double at Five Guys.